Google Search Suggest May Be Win/Win/Lose/Lose

Google Search Suggest is a new assist that many keyword searchers are now seeing when they do Google searches.  If you have questions, then there is even a FAQ page that will answer most of them.  Here is how Google Suggest is described:

What is Google Suggest?
As you type into the search box, Google Suggest guesses what you’re typing and offers suggestions in real time. This is similar to Google’s "Did you mean?" feature that offers alternative spellings for your query after you search, except that it works in real time. For example, if you type "bass," Google Suggest might offer a list of refinements that include "bass fishing" or "bass guitar." Similarly, if you type in only part of a word, like "prog," Google Suggest might offer you refinements like "programming," "programming languages," "progesterone," or "progressive." You can choose one by scrolling up or down the list with the arrow keys or mouse.

One interesting feature of Google Suggest is that items appear with a green number next to them representing the approximate number of results that would return for the suggested query.  So if you like what the rest of the crowd was looking for when they typed your phrase, then you can select one of these popular choices.

The selection shown is clearly determined by some algorithm.  Sometimes the choices shown are not at all obvious.  For example in searching for my user name, bwelford, after typing ‘bwel’ I got the following results:

google search suggest

In this case, the algorithm seems to be assuming that this is a typo.  The choices offered are reasonable, but the order they are presented seems to have no logic.  It is not in order of the number of searches done with that expression.  Does the algorithm throw in a random ordering to spread keyword choices among the possible contenders?  That is a mystery for the moment.

As with any change, there are winners and losers.  One clear winner would seem to be the searcher.  If and only if they choose to do so, they can more quickly get to the item they had in mind provided it is on the list. 

An even bigger winner is probably Google itself.  This mechanism is likely to funnel visitors towards a more restricted set of choices of keyword search pages.  Given that such search pages have Adword ads on them, this funneling could well mean that AdWords advertisers are automatically competing on more restricted options.  This could therefore mean higher Pay Per Click revenues to Google.  If this theory is correct, this could have a significant improvement for Google’s bottom line.

… and who are the losers?  If Google is making more money on AdWords, then this means that AdWords advertisers are losers here.  They must pay out more for each click on these more visited web pages, given that they are now competing with more AdWords advertisers wishing to appear for these more attractive keyword phrases.

The other losers may well be owners of web pages that have always ranked well for long tail searches. As others have suggested, Google Suggest may well influence the traffic coming to any given web page.  This funneling of searchers’ choices might sound like a small change but it can have a big effect on traffic.  If most of that traffic was coming through a long-tail search, where someone typed in a fairly long phrase, they may now cease to do that.  Such a searcher may choose the closest concept among the items presented.  Unless the searcher is persistent and insists on typing out their long-tail search query, they will now never come to that particular web page.

Since the winners for this move vastly outnumber the losers, and Google is among the winners, it seems unlikely that this added feature will disappear. We must all learn to live with it.  Search Engine Optimization was already proving to be a challenge with other Google changes and Google Suggest now raises the stakes considerably.

13 thoughts on “Google Search Suggest May Be Win/Win/Lose/Lose”

  1. It’s somewhat the same with the search panel with a firefox browser at the topmost right. Though, the ‘suggestion’ works with other search engines you choose along the selection.

  2. Each human has different thoughts and big number depends on what technologies are available. I haven’t used that feature ever because I always know what I am going to do.

  3. Personally, it annoys me when technology tries to think for me in this way. That’s why I’ve turned that option off on my cell phone. That being said, I am a horrific speller, so maybe I should take advantage of it. As far as whether it helps bloggers find better keywords, It looks like it could. I don’t understand the whole algorythm thing myself, so I’d like to hear what other bloggers thinkg about it.

  4. I’m using Google suggest for my keyword research. But I do have doubts on the search amount. Firstly, we are not sure what is the unit. Is it counts per month, or counts per quarter, or what? Second thing is, when I counter check the search amount with other keyword analyzer, it showed quite a significant variance. One thing for sure, if it came out in Google Suggest, then there probably are people searching for the term.

  5. If this is true and search suggest favours of adwords advertisers, does this not create a disadvantage to everyone? If I dont use adwords but have a better site, better content etc, does this mean I can still be penalised for not using adwords? Or am I misunderstanding this?

  6. Well, Google has been in business for quite a while now and they know how to lure clients. This part is also a further step in carrying out the same strategy. But I personally like Google Suggest as it minimized the workload on the user end.

  7. I love search suggest. It helps me see what people are searching for. That is very useful information and now it is free and instant, plus I get to see how many results for each keyword phrase. Very useful info indeed.


  8. From the user viewpoint, Google Suggest is a good tool. The most obvious benefit is to help us choose the right song performed by a favorite band or singer when their names listed at the end of the song title. 🙂

  9. I really like search suggest because it makes things easier thou some of the suggestions they come up with are not related. The other advantage is that you can see what is the most popular keyword.

Comments are closed.